|
The series consists of
153 consecutive patients who received autologous
cultured chondrocyte implantations for various
defects of the knee. Clinical follow-up ranged
from 1 week to 94 months. Most patients had
arthroscopic evaluation; a subset had biopsy and
histological evaluations. Patients presented
with cartilaginous defects of the femoral
condyle, patella, tibia, a combination of these,
or osteochondritis dissecans, with or without
non-cartilaginous defects such as anterior
cruciate ligament damage requiring repair.
Following autologous
cultured chondrocyte implantation, patients were
routinely followed for various durations. All
patients were retrospectively classified as
having one of the three clinical outcomes:
resumed all activities, some improvement, or no
improvement. Clinical outcomes were also
reported for patient subgroups including: 1)
those with femoral condyle lesions who had at
least 18 months of follow-up, and 2) those who
failed an earlier procedure. Most patients were
also assessed for arthroscopic outcomes and some
patients were assessed for histological
outcomes.
Clinical Outcome -
Patients with Femoral Condyle Lesions
A total of 78 of 153
patients in the Swedish series had femoral
condyle lesions with or without concurrent
non-cartilaginous knee lesions. Patients had one
or more defects ranging in size from <1-20 cm2.
Approximately 90% of the patients had defects of
<10 cm2. Clinical outcomes are
shown below for 40 patients who received
autologous cultured chondrocytes and were
evaluable after at least 18 months of follow-up
(median = 25; range = 18-94 months). In this
evaluation, 70% of the patients demonstrated
some clinical benefit when compared to their
pre-operative condition.
| Defect |
Resumed all
activities |
Some
improvement |
No
improvement |
Total |
| Femoral
Condyle |
7 (29%) |
8 (33%) |
9 (38%) |
24 |
Femoral
Condyle plus other
Non-Cartilage Repair |
4 (25%) |
9 (56%) |
3 (19%) |
16 |
| Total |
11 (28%) |
17 (42%) |
12 (30%) |
40 |
No apparent association
of clinical outcomes with lesion size or cell
dose could be demonstrated.
Clinical Outcome -
Patients With Osteochondritis Dissecans Lesions
Clinical outcomes are
shown below for 12 patients who received
autologous cultured chondrocytes and were
evaluable after at least 18 months of follow-up
(median = 25; range = 18-94 months). In this
evaluation, 83% of the patients demonstrated
some clinical benefit when compared to their
pre-operative condition.
| Defect |
Resumed all
activities |
Some
improvement |
No
improvement |
Total |
| Osteochondritis Dissecans |
6 (50%) |
4 (33%) |
2 (17%) |
12 |
Clinical Outcome -
Failed Earlier Procedures
Debridement of the
cartilage defect is often performed along with
Carticel® (autologous cultured
chondrocytes) administration. To help
differentiate the effects of the autologous
cultured chondrocyte implantation procedure from
those of debridement alone, an analysis was
performed on 22 patients who had failed prior
debridement and had a follow-up period after
autologous cultured chondrocyte implantation
which was greater than the time period to
failure of their initial debridement. These
patients had a range of cartilage defects. At
the end of follow-up, 5 (23%) patients had a
functional outcome rating of "resumed all
activities," 8 (36%) patients had a rating
of "some improvement," and 9 (41%)
patients had a rating of "no
improvement." Thus, 13/22 (59%) patients
who had failed an earlier debridement had
outcomes following autologous cultured
chondrocyte implantation which were more
favorable and durable than those following their
earlier therapy.
Histological Outcome
Twenty-two of the initial 23 patients in the
Swedish series had histological evaluation of
biopsies from the transplant site. Fifteen of
those patients had defects of the femoral
condyle and 7 had defects of the patella. Six of
the 15 femoral condyle patients showed only
hyaline cartilage on their biopsy, 5 had a
mixture of hyaline and fibrocartilage, and 4 had
only fibrocartilage. Of the 6 patients with only
hyaline cartilage on biopsy, 2 had minimal to no
defects and 4 had more extensive defects (e.g.,
fissures, fibrillations, etc.).
Arthroscopic Outcome
Most of the 153 patients had arthroscopy. The
quality of repair observed at arthroscopy
correlated with the clinical outcomes. A
substantial number of patients were noted at
arthroscopy to have tissue hypertrophy (see
Adverse Events).
Data from the US registry
included 38 patients with femoral condyle
lesions who received the Carticel®(autologous
cultured chondrocytes) product and had at least
12 months of follow-up. Only functional outcome
data were collected; no arthroscopic or
histologic data are available. Although these
patients were rated according to outcome
measurements different from those used in the
Swedish series, the results were consistent with
the Swedish experience.
Two post-marketing
studies are under way to evaluate the long term
durability of the Carticel®repair in
patients who have failed a prior surgical repair
procedure. Prior surgical repair procedures are
surgical interventions intended to correct
cartilaginous defects such as marrow stimulation
techniques, transplantation of cells or tissues,
or debridement followed by an adequate
rehabilitation program. Repair procedures,
however, do not include lavage, biopsy, or
diagnostic arthroscopy.
Carticel® is
not indicated for the treatment of cartilage
damage associated with osteoarthritis.
Carticel®should
only be used in conjunction with debridement,
placement of a periosteal flap and
rehabilitation. The independent contributions of
the autologous cultured chondrocytes and other
components of the therapy to outcome are
unknown. Data regarding functional outcomes
beyond 3 years of autologous cultured
chondrocyte treatment are limited.
Carticel®
should not be used in patients with a known
history of anaphylaxis to gentamicin. The biopsy
medium used to transport the cartilage biopsies
and the culture medium used during the first
passage of cells contains DMEM with gentamicin.
All subsequent processing is conducted
aseptically and utilizes cell culture medium
that does not contain gentamicin; however, trace
quantities of gentamicin may still be present.
Carticel®
should not be used in patients with known
sensitivities to materials of bovine origin. The
cell culture medium used during the culturing of
the cells contains bovine serum. The medium used
to package and transport the cells does not
contain serum; however, trace quantities of
bovine-derived proteins may still be present.
Instability of the knee
or abnormal weight-distribution within the joint
may adversely affect the success of the
procedure and should be corrected prior to
Carticel® implantation. Abnormal
varus loading of the medial compartment may
jeopardize the implant. When treating trochlear
defects, abnormal patellar tracking must be
corrected, if possible.
Physical activity should
be resumed according to the rehabilitation plan
recommended by the physician. Vigorous activity
may compromise the durability of clinical
benefit from Carticel® (autologous cultured
chondrocytes). Tissue hypertrophy was an
observed adverse event in clinical studies (see
Adverse Reactions). Patients who develop
clinical signs of tissue hypertrophy should be
evaluated with arthroscopy.
Both the long-term effect
of cartilage harvesting on knee function and the
long term safety of cartilage implantation are
unknown.
The safety of the
Carticel® product is unknown in
patients with malignancy in the area of
cartilage biopsy or implant. The potential
exists for in vitro expansion and subsequent
implantation of malignant or dysplastic cells
present in biopsy tissue. In addition,
implantation of normal autologous chondrocytes
could potentially stimulate growth of malignant
cells in the area of the implant, although there
have been no reported incidents in humans.
The Carticel®
product is shipped following a preliminary
sterility test with a 48 hour incubation to
determine absence of microbial growth. Final (14
day incubation) sterility test results are not
available at the time of implantation.
Do Not Refrigerate,
Freeze, or Incubate the Carticel®
Shipping Container or its Contents. The
Carticel® product consists of
viable, autologous cells packaged and labeled
for implantation within specified time limits.
The Carticel® transport box should
be held at room temperature and remain closed
until the time of implantation to ensure proper
storage conditions for the cells.
Do Not Sterilize. If the
Vial is Damaged or Sterility has been
Compromised, Do Not Use.
Tissue Hypertrophy
Of 86 patients with a range of defects and at
least 18 months of follow-up, 37 (43%) had
hypertrophic tissue noted at follow-up
arthroscopy. In those clinically evaluable
patients with femoral condyle defects, 10 of 40
(25%) had some hypertrophic tissue noted at
follow-up arthroscopy. The hypertrophic tissue
ranged from a small amount of diffuse excess
tissue at the implantation site, to a distinct
ridge of tissue at the margin of the implant, to
widespread excess tissue throughout the joint
space. Some of these patients had clinical
symptoms including painful crepitations or
"catching." Symptoms generally
resolved after arthroscopic resection of the
hypertrophic tissue. Ten percent of patients
with hypertrophy required additional treatment
after hypertrophic tissue recurred following
initial resection.
Registry data on 891
patients who received implantation of autologous
cultured chondrocytes were derived from
voluntary reporting by surgeons and do not
include those from routine arthroscopy; 131
patients had a follow up of at least 18 months.
After correcting for differences in follow up
time, cumulative rates of patients requiring
additional operative procedures were calculated;
18% of all patients required an additional
procedure within 18 months and 11% of all
patients required (at a minimum) shaving,
trimming, debridement, or chondroplasty.
Implantation of the
Carticel® product is performed
during arthrotomy and requires both preparation
of the defect bed and a periosteal flap to
secure the implant. Complete hemostasis must be
achieved prior to periosteal fixation and cell
implantation. See the Carticel®
Surgical Manual, GTR document #65021 for
instructions on performance of these procedures.
Cell Aspiration and
Implantation
(For complete surgical instructions, see
Surgical Manual #65021.)
NOTE: The exterior of the
Carticel® vial containing the
cultured cells is NOT sterile. Follow strict
sterile technique protocols.
When treating a defect
which requires multiple vials of cells,
resuspend, aspirate and inject one vial at a
time.
- Remove red plastic lid from vial. Wipe the
vial surface and lid with alcohol.
- Inspect vial contents for particulates,
discoloration or turbidity. The cellular
product appears as a yellowish clump in the
bottom of the vial. Do not administer if
contents appear turbid prior to cell
suspension.
- While holding vial in a vertical position,
insert the needle of the intraspinal
catheter into the vial. The needle must be
positioned just above the fluid level.
Slowly remove the inner needle from the
catheter, leaving flexible tip behind.
Attach a tuberculin syringe to catheter.
- Lower the catheter tip into the media and
position just above the cell pellet.
Aspirate all the medium from the vial
leaving only the cell pellet behind. Slowly
expel medium back into the vial. This action
will break the cell pellet and resuspend the
cells in the medium.
- Lower the catheter tip to the base of the
vial and aspirate all contents into syringe,
leaving the vial empty. Slowly inject the
contents into the vial again. This will
assure complete suspension of the cells.
Repeat these steps as needed to ensure all
cells are resuspended. Cell resuspension is
complete when cell particles are no longer
apparent, and the medium is a consistent,
"cloudy" mixture. Aspirate all
contents of vial into syringe. Always hold
syringe vertical to keep an air pocket at
the proximal end of syringe.
- Insert the catheter tip through the
superior opening of the periosteal chamber
at the site of the defect. Advance catheter
to most inferior aspect of the defect.
- Slowly inject a cell dose while moving the
catheter tip from side to side and
withdrawing the catheter proximally. This
will ensure an even distribution of the
cells throughout the defect.
- Complete the implantation by closing the
superior opening of the periosteum as
instructed. See Carticel® (autologous
cultured chondrocytes) Surgical Manual.
For more information or
to obtain Genzyme Biosurgery documents or
references, contact:
Genzyme Biosurgery
64 Sidney Street
Cambridge, MA 02139-4136 USA
Telephone: 800-453-6948 or 617-494-8484
Fax: 617-252-0877
Carticel® is
a Registered Trademark of Genzyme Corporation,
Cambridge, MA.
65001
Revision G 2/2000
|